Search

 

Saturday 22nd September

Stirling County 13 v 52 Boroughmuir

Scorers
 

Stirling County

 

Boroughmuir

     
Tries
Graham Lindsay
 
 
 
 
 
  Tries
Ben Fisher
Sean Crombie
Angus Martyn (2)
Elgan O'Donnell
Malcolm Clapperton
Andy Hadden
Conversions Graham Lindsay   Conversions Elgan O'Donnell (7) 
Penalties Johnny Hope (2)   Penalties Elgan O'Donnell 
Drop Goals      Drop Goals  

 

 

 

 

Reporter: Simon Furnivall

Boroughmuir this evening can look down on the Scottish Hydro Electric Premiership from a lofty position after their crushing win over Stirling County , coupled with Watsonians defeat of Currie, saw the Meggetland side rise to the top of the table for the first time this season. Things hadn’t looked so simple at the interval as ’Muir lead only 6-10 and had seen attacking positions pass them by, but a second half try count of six to one in favour of the Edinburgh side saw them romp home with a five point win.

Playing the first half into the wind, Boroughmuir began brightly and had a try on the board inside three minutes. Ben Fisher broke well up the left wing and Malcolm Clapperton chipped ahead to win good field position when Stirling wing Steve McDonald failed to hold onto the ball. From the scrum, fly-half Matt Cannon had a dart at the line before Fisher powered his way over from eight yards. Elgan O’Donnell added the conversion in what would be a highly accurate day for the Kiwi centre.

Stirling had given Currie a serious run for their money last week in a determined forward effort, and so were not a side to be taken lightly, particularly on their home patch. They showed just why from the restart, lock Bruce MacFarlane and Number 8 Justin Matheson marshalling the pack very well in a series of attacks at the ’Muir line. The eventually won a penalty, which centre Jonathan Hope struck between the uprights.

Hope missed an attempt to reduce the gap to a single point in the seventeenth minute when he pushed a penalty wide of the posts after Stephen Ruddick had been penalised for holding onto the ball in the tackle. Hope was given a chance to redeem himself when ’Muir scrum half Greg Cottrell was harshly yellow-carded for a deliberate knock-on, and this time the Stirling centre made no mistake with his penalty effort.

Boroughmuir were still the better side, and they didn’t let their numerical disadvantage change that. With Andy Knight replacing Rob Cairns for the duration of the sin-binning, and Joni Hare on for Olly Brown after the flanker took a knock, they began to get themselves on the front foot once more. However, they continued with their early season trend of making too many errors as at least three potential scoring positions were thrown away.

Those missed chances very nearly came back to bite them quickly, Graham Calder making a nuisance of himself at a Boroughmuir scrum deep in the Stirling half. The scrum half managed to hack the ball forward for Allan Robertson to chase, and only a very late intervention by Ruddick and Clapperton saw the home full back held up over the Boroughmuir try line.

’Muir were able to resist the forward barrage which Stirling threw at them in a desperate attempt to score the try, bodies were put on the line in a superb defensive effort from the visitors. And when they finally emerged with the ball and broke upfield, they won a penalty inside the Stirling twenty-two which O’Donnell slotted between the posts five minutes before the break.

The second half saw Boroughmuir begin with the same sort of flourish that they had in the first, and only the referee’s whistle prevented them from scoring a try almost straight from the kick-off. After Graeme McCallum took clean line-out ball, Angus Martyn directed a drive which took them to within a metre or so of the Stirling line. Freddie Lait picked up and dived over the line, but the whistle sounded to indicate that Joni Hare had been caught preventing winger Graham Lindsay from trying to tackle Lait.

The try did come soon thereafter, and it was hooker Sean Crombie who touched down. From wide on the right, Matt Cannon and Rory Couper moved the ball through the hands, allowing Crombie to show an excellent turn of pace and strength, going outside three men and diving to beat Ross Logan in the corner. O’Donnell added the conversion from wide on the left.

Boroughmuir needed to start turning the screw with the wind at their backs, and were given a little let off when Hope pushed another penalty attempt wide of the sticks. The third try, however, quickly stuck the knife into the hosts. Starting when Fergus Pringle stole a line-out just inside the Boroughmuir twenty-two, the Edinburgh side worked their way upfield, eventually winning a scrum just ten metres from the Stirling line. The ball was well recycled through a number of phases, and when Cannon made a half-break, Angus Martyn was on his shoulder to take the pass and stroll over the line. O’Donnell again added the extra two.

If the third had created the wound, it was the fourth that killed off any chance Stirling had. After the home forwards had relentlessly pounded on the ’Muir defence, Pringle, Fisher and Martyn combined to wrest the ball back into ’Muir’s possession. Joni Hare carried out of the twenty-two and Cannon and Clapperton provided the links before Couper delivered the scoring pass to O’Donnell, the inside centre unchallenged as he raced in from thirty-five metres. He converted his own score, and the gap was a more-than-healthy twenty-five points.

Stirling were given brief hope when Lindsay intercepted Cannon’s long pass and ran in from forty metres, before converting the score himself, but ’Muir soon countered with a fifth score of their own. Through yet more turnover ball, Crombie burst up the left wing and found Clapperton in support. Couper just about managed to keep control of the ball when it got to him, and he fed Martyn, who went outside and then inside home fly-half Massey Tuhakaraina and touched down under the posts. O’Donnell, inevitably, added the conversion.

The game was coming towards its close, but ’Muir still had the time to find two more tries. Stirling didn’t want to go down without a fight and they tried to take the game back to ’Muir, but when Martyn turned ball over in the middle of the park, Clapperton was found with enough space to dink a little chip forward. He hacked on again under challenge from Mark Hunter, and then when he slid down on the ball ten metres from the line, he pirouetted around Tuhakaraina and strolled under the posts.

The final nail in the coffin came in injury time, and it was substitute Andy Hadden who hammered it in. With Stirling still throwing the ball around, Nigel Drapper won turnover ball on the twenty-two, and when it was moved through the line, Ruddick slipped an inside pass to Hadden, who coasted over the line. O’Donnell converted both the final tries to ensure his 100% record for the day remained intact as the final whistle sounded.

For the fourth week running, Boroughmuir have won without putting in the perfect performance. And whilst the first half attacking performance may have left something to be desired, the defensive effort that was put in throughout the match should be commended. Stirling tried countless times to attack round the fringes and through rolling mauls, but each time they were repelled, and when they spun the ball into the backs, they found the midfield defence to be equally impenetrable. Watsonians will provide a stiff challenge to ’Muir’s excellent start, but there is no reason why the game cannot be approached with confidence.

Boroughmuir: Stephen Ruddick; Robert Cairns, Malcolm Clapperton, Elgan O'Donnell, Rory Couper; Matt Cannon, Greg Cottrell, Danny Rutterford, Sean Crombie, Freddie Lait; Fergus Pringle, Graeme McCallum; Olly Brown, Ben Fisher, Angus Martyn. Subs Used Nigel Drapper, Davie Cunningham. Joni Hare, Andy Knight, Andy Hadden