Search

 

Saturday 10th November

Edinburgh Academicals 12 v 14 Boroughmuir

Scorers
 

Edinburgh Academicals

 

Boroughmuir

     
Tries
 
  Tries
Rory Couper
Conversions     Conversions  
Penalties Greg Laidlaw (4)   Penalties Elgan O'Donnell (3)
Drop Goals     Drop Goals  

 

 

 

 

Reporter: Simon Furnivall

Boroughmuir have become used to haute cuisine this season, but today they served up the rugby equivalent of stew and dumplings. They were harried into mistakes throughout the eighty minutes by an Accies side that were desperate for a win to ease their troubles at the wrong end of the table. They even fell behind for the first time in the eighty-second minute, but showed enough character and determination to come back and claim the victory.

It was perhaps ironic indeed that a match so void of points scoring swung either way so late in the day, and Accies will no doubt feel that they once again contrived to lose a game they should have won, but Boroughmuir likewise believed they had done more than enough to merit coming away with the four points.

In hindsight, the game was never likely to be a high scoring affair. On a cold day with a strong wind whipping across Raeburn Place, Accies only had to look as far as late last season for inspiration as to how to stop the Boroughmuir machine. On that occasion at the same venue, the hosts claimed a thoroughly deserved victory and a place at Murrayfield in the Scottish Cup Final. Today, their tactics were much the same, trying to stifle the Meggetland attacking threat and play a territorial game to the strength of their forward pack.

For much of the match they managed just that, the lineout was dominated by blue and white shirts and they flooded the breakdown in an attempt to win vital turnover ball. However, it was ’Muir who scored the first points, and they did so attacking quickly after stealing ball from the Accies pack. As so often it was Angus Martyn who pried the ball from opposition hands and tore away into space. He was chased down before reaching the line, but good support and quickly recycled ball saw Rory Couper in at the corner.

Accies replied with a penalty through Edinburgh professional fly-half Greg Laidlaw and they continued to apply the pressure for the rest of the half. In this period, and the opening ten minutes of the second half, when Accies controlled both possession and territory, they threw everything they could muster at the Boroughmuir line. Time and again though they were repelled, always a ’Muir shirt was to be found in the way at the crucial juncture, and with fifty minutes gone, only a trading of penalties between Laidlaw and Elgan O’Donnell had added to the score.

In the run up to Laidlaw’s second successful kick, both sides had been reduced to fourteen men. Boroughmuir’s Olly Brown and Accies’ Greg Campbell took exception to each other at a ruck on the ’Muir line. Punches were swung, some connected, and both were sent to cool down on the touchline for ten minutes.

Laidlaw and O’Donnell swapped penalties for the second time in the match either side of the hour mark to keep the gap at a mere two points, 9-11, but by this time it was Boroughmuir who were in the ascendancy. They camped themselves on the Accies line, a series of scrums ended in Olly Brown, newly returned to the field, being stopped just inches short of a try in the corner whilst replacement lock forward Stuart Waddell made  a strong burst towards the line and only the close attentions of the Accies defence forced a knock-on as the line beckoned.

Accies finally cleared their lines as the game moved into injury time, and when they swept up an over throw at the Boroughmuir lineout, they had the perfect platform. A penalty was awarded for a high tackle and Laidlaw lined up the kick from forty metres. There never seemed a doubt in his mind that it would dissect the posts, and the roar that greeted its success belied the small numbers of the crowd.

The hosts’ problem may have been that, at this point, it looked as if the players believed they had won the game, as much as the fans did. Boroughmuir had no intentions of letting go that easily, however, and Tom Bury flew up the pitch to charge down a clearance on the Accies twenty-two. The home side won a scrum, but again ’Muir showed their winning character, Sean Crombie striking against the head and when scrum-half Mike Campbell encroached offside, O’Donnell slotted a penalty from in front of the posts to finally claim the victory.

It was not the champagne rugby that we have become used to this season; it was not even a five point haul as had been collected in each of the previous nine matches. It was, however, a win where such results are notoriously difficult to come by. There is little doubt that Accies will beat teams at Raeburn in the second half of the season, playing as they did today they are not a bottom-of-the-table side, and as coach Eamon John said afterwards, not every game can be won by knock-out, sometimes it’s just enough to take the decision on points.

Boroughmuir: Stephen Ruddick; Tom Bury, Malcolm Clapperton, Elgan O'Donnell, Rory Couper; Matt Cannon, Calum Cusiter; Freddie Lait, Sean Crombie, Cam Ward; Fergus Pringle, Graeme McCallum; Olly Brown, Euan Matheson, Angus Martyn. Subs Used Conor Costigan, Stuart Waddell, Greg Cottrell - Not Used: Davie Cunningham, Ed Mills