Search

 

Saturday 22nd March

Boroughmuir 18 v 14 Edinburgh Academicals

Scorers
 

Boroughmuir

 

Edinburgh Academicals

     
Tries
Euan Matheson
Ben Fisher
  Tries
Iain Berthinussen
Conversions Elgan O'Donnell   Conversions  
Penalties Elgan O'Donnell (2)   Penalties David Blair (2)
Drop Goals      Drop Goals David Blair

 

 

 

 

Reporter: Simon Furnivall

For the second time this season Boroughmuir scored late in the game to steal a win from under the noses of Edinburgh Academicals. Whilst it was Elgan O’Donnell’s late penalty at Raeburn Place, it was today a Ben Fisher try in injury time at Meggetland which ensured the victory stayed with the home side.

Though they may have had a case for deserving the win at Raeburn Place, had Accies walked away from Meggetland victorious it would have been largely down to Boroughmuir’s inability to kill the game off when they had it by the throat halfway through the second half.

’Muir welcomed Matt Cannon back to the starting line-up after he had missed the cup defeat to Melrose but fielded a new-look back three – James White and Rob Cairns on the wings with Greg Cottrell at full back – in place of the more familiar names. It seemed certain that Cannon would have his work cut out for him as he faced Edinburgh professional David Blair in the Accies’ fly-half role. ’Muir’s Englishman rose well to the challenge and looked lively in the early stages before being forced off with a shoulder injury that necessitated a reshuffle in the back line.

The visitors had begun the game well, Blair settling quickly back into the side having played for Iain Barnes’ team in the first few weeks of the season. Their intent was clear, using their talented pack to attack round the fringes but Boroughmuir’s defence held strong against them and their was little threat of a try in the opening stages. Indeed, it was Boroughmuir who took the lead in the tenth minute, a break up the middle of the park brought to an end when referee Ted Coutts whistled for a penalty against Accies which O’Donnell stroked between the posts.

Accies were clearly up for the game, as one would expect from a side who’s Premier One survival is still very much under threat. On the quarter hour they were awarded a penalty when David Cunningham was caught offside at a breakdown and Blair levelled the scores with a clean strike between the sticks.

Blair was using the wind well, booming kicks downfield to put his forwards in the position they wanted to be, but no matter what their eight threw at ’Muir’s, they couldn’t find a way through. They sensed an opportunity, however, when Boroughmuir suffered a double injury blow within just a few minutes. First Cannon had to leave the field with his shoulder causing obvious discomfort, scrum half Stuart McGee replacing him on the field whilst Cottrell moved up from full back to take over the fly-half role. Just moments later, captain Fergus Pringle was helped off after he took a blow in a tackle, replaced by Euan Matheson.

Blair showed his nouse to test new full back James White early on, and Accies were firmly on the front foot, laying siege to the Boroughmuir line. For nigh on the rest of the half they camped themselves deep in the home side’s twenty-two. Time after time they attacked round the fringes only to find a wall of green and blue defence, props Freddie Lait and Cam Ward as well as flankers Angus Martyn and Olly Brown very much to the fore in the effort. The visitor’s were left cursing Matt Coupar’s butter-fingers, however, as when they finally worked an overlap on the right the former Watsonians wing failed to take a seemingly simple pass with the try-line at his mercy.

Making the most of their reprieve, ’Muir quickly worked their way upfield and O’Donnell landed his second penalty of the game from just left of the posts. The scores were tied at the break though, Accies quickly won the ball from the restart and Blair dropped back in the pocket to slot a drop goal from thirty metres with the last kick of the half.

Boroughmuir had some regrouping to do at the interval and whatever was said looked to have worked a treat as early breaks by James White up the left wing and Cam Ward up the right showed more threat than in the majority of the first half put together. With four minutes on the clock in the second half the visitors were caught with their hands in the ruck and O’Donnell had a chance to put his die ahead for the third time but dragged his penalty effort across the face of the posts.

The hosts’ pack was also beginning to get the better of their Accies counterparts as was shown by Cunningham – playing his last game at Meggetland before retiring at the end of the season – made his trademark strike against the head at the scrum, the second time he had done so in the match.

With thirteen minutes of the half gone Boroughmuir struck what should have been the decisive blow in the match, and it was thanks again to their pack. Accies won a penalty in the ’Muir twenty-two, but after Blair had kicked for touch and Nathan Pike had won the lineout, Lait appeared with a crucial turnover and the lines were cleared.

Accies now had a lineout on halfway, but it was turned over by ’Muir. Cunningham broke with the energy of a twenty year-old but just in time he remembered he’s considerably older than that and found Matheson in support. There didn’t seem much of anywhere for Matheson to go but with pace and strength of which any winger would have been proud, he shrugged off three defenders and powered his way up the touchline to score. O’Donnell added a wonderful conversion.

The game was now firmly in their hands and Boroughmuir should have gone on to pull themselves well clear and canter towards victory. Had they kept hold of the ball and worked the phases they may have done just that, but all too often they tried to rush a pass out of contact or kicked possession away cheaply.

After hanging on for the best part of twenty minutes, Accies seemed to realise that they were only one score behind and redoubled their efforts. Another attempt at a forward drive was repelled without too much trouble, but with just thirteen minutes remaining Blair cut the gap to four points with his third successful penalty of the match.

There was a confidence beginning to seep through the visitors, and inside the final ten minutes they scored what they hoped was the crucial try. Blair made a break in the middle of the park and found Coupar on his shoulder. The winger stormed onto the ball, but as he was hauled down by Cottrell just inside the Boroughmuir half, managed to slip a pass to Iain Berthinussen. The centre still had work to do, but he slipped outside White and beat Cairns in a footrace to score in the corner. Blair’s conversion attempt skidded across the face of the posts and Accies lead remained at a single point.

Accies’ game plan now came to the fore as their forwards tried to tick the clock down with an endless run of pick-and-go attempts around the fringes of the rucks. The chance to wrest the win their way almost fell to ’Muir with three minutes remaining when a charge down by Calum Cusiter saw the scrum half scamper down the left wing in pursuit of the ball. He hacked it forward towards the line but was just beaten to the touchdown by Berthinussen.

’Muir now had the bit between their teeth though and with their hands on the ball they worked a series of attacks. McGee and Martyn linked up well down the right flank but found their path blocked. They kept hold of the ball, however, and when it came to O’Donnell inside the Accies’ twenty-two, the Kiwi centre looped a long pass out to Fisher who had a clear run to the line for the winning score. The eighty minutes were up as O’Donnell’s conversion attempt drifted left, but with plenty of injury time to come there was still hope for the visitors.

Despite having much of the ball as they tried to work an opening – and looking dangerous as they flung the ball around the park – nothing worked for them and after replacement prop Conor Costigan had put in a wonderful driving tackle on the right flank and Cusiter had snaffled the turnover, Cottrell kicked to touch and brought the curtain down on an entertaining game.

Whilst hardly the most crucial win in Boroughmuir’s league winning season, it was a welcome response to last week’s cup exit at the Greenyards. It was also a fitting way for David Cunningham and Graeme McCallum, two stalwarts of the club for well over a decade to see out their final game at Meggetland. Both will be missed on the field next season and hopefully they can come away from their last game at Melrose next week with another good win.

Boroughmuir: Greg Cottrell; James White, Malcolm Clapperton, Elgan O'Donnell, Rob Cairns; Matt Cannon, Calum Cusiter; Freddie Lait, Davie Cunningham, Cam Ward; Fergus Pringle, Graeme McCallum; Olly Brown, Euan Matheson, Angus Martyn. Subs Used Conor Costigan, Euan Matheson. Joni Hare, Stuart McGee